Stage Coach Pizza Co. - Cave Spring (GA)

5 /5 Michelle Carroll: We accidentally went in right before closing. We left but the owner stopped us in the parking lot and INSISTED we come inside and eat. The pizza and cheese sticks were amazing as always. You don’t get hospitality like that anywhere any more. We are so glad they opened this great restaurant in Cave Spring. And our granddaughter LOVED the giant cookie!

3 /5 Michelle Warren: The restaurant is decorated very nice…there is not a lot of seating…30 minute + wait. Our service was not great our waitress was super stressed as were the others. I tried to order a salad but they were out of salads.. The pizza was mediocre…nothing special!! It appeared to have been cooked more on one side than the other!! But one thing I did notice was that the hostess (Olivia)…was very attentive to everyone’s needs…from seating them, cleaning tables and even coming to your table to ask if you needed anything and also offering a very warm smile!!

5 /5 Isaac: THE place to eat delicious pizza, Friendly staff and family owned. The pepperoni or meat lovers with some mozzerla sticks is the go to order, thank me later. Usually always fast turnaround, my dad lives 3 miles away and hell call them and come pick it up and itll already be ready and fresh.

4 /5 Henry Matthew (Southeast Kayak Dude): Interesting old building with nice original wood. Pizza is good, nice people working there, worth a visit if youre hungry for pizza in Cave Spring.

5 /5 Slade: Stagecoach Pizza in Cave Spring, GA, is a hidden gem that truly captures the heart of small-town charm. From the moment you walk in, youre greeted by a cozy, western vibe that feels like a step back in time, creating a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere. The pizza is absolutely top-notch—perfectly cooked with a crispy, golden crust and fresh, flavorful toppings that leave you wanting more with every bite. But what really sets this place apart is the exceptional staff. Theyre always friendly, attentive, and eager to make sure your experience is nothing short of fantastic. Whether youre a local or just passing through, Stagecoach Pizza is a must-visit!