The Crushed Tomato - LaFayette (GA)

3 /5 Jason in Georgia: Crushed Tomato is a gorgeous location in a well preserved, historic building. They know, tell and honor the history. The atmosphere and service are excellent. And for "sit down" pizza not from a franchise recipe, prices are fair and staff is terrific. Issue today was ordering a four topping pizza with almost nothing on it. This is not cheap pizza, nor is it terribly expensive. As example, mine had pepperoni, mushroom, green pepper and bacon. Or ideally it would have. I was really surprised at this sparse, large pizza so I counted a slice purely out of curiosity. One piece of green pepper, one mushroom, two pepperoni and a dusting of bacon which was imperceptible. I get it, groceries are expensive. This is not how to economize on a $25.00 pizza. Would I return? Absolutely. This was noticeable, and borderline rude. I hope this was an anomaly. Raise the price a dollar or two, but do put toppings on pizza.

5 /5 Barbara Breneman: We are new to the area. Trying new eateries. Definitely will be returning to this place. We ordered the gluten free cauliflower crust deluxe pizza. It was served quickly and was very hot right out the oven. Server was pleasant and helpful. Next visit we will probably try the calzone.

5 /5 American Girl: Came in with my husband for our 30th wedding anniversary. This was our first time visiting, so we had to try several items on the menu. The food was fresh and most everything is from scratch. My husband’s family is from Italy and they owed an Italian restaurant for over 20 years, So we can be kind of picky. Thankfully, we were not disappointed! The food tastes like his uncle from Italy makes it, everything was so delicious & the cheesecake was Amazing!! The server was very nice and she gave us all the history on the building. It was a very lovely dinner and we are so happy we chose to go here. We are definitely Looking forward to going back.

5 /5 Heather Fricks: Got the small portion of chicken Alfredo and my husband got the rattlesnake calzone. Im curious how big the large portion of Alfredo is because I couldnt eat all the small. Food was really good. My husband said that was one of the best calzones hes ever had. They were very busy the day we went and it didnt take too long to get our food. I THINK our servers name was Jennifer, and to be as busy as they were, she was on top of things. They all seemed to be. Great place.

4 /5 Kristi Holcomb: We took our granddaughter - She wanted spaghetti (we werent hungry). One childs spaghetti dinner, one appetizer of garlic bites, 1 childs drink, 2 adult drinks - $31 + tip. $37 is a lot when the adults didnt eat. Good food, but pricey.