Jim N Nicks Bar-B-Q - Fayetteville (GA)

4 /5 A. Kidd: The food was spectacular, the service divine, the atmosphere rustic and chic! I got the brisket sandwich and fries. The fries are well seasoned and come in these metal containers to keep them warm! The brisket melts in the mouth at the first bite! Though it wasn’t as warm as I was expecting, it was still wonderful! Next time I’m going to try the brisket by itself and not in the sandwich.

4 /5 Lydia Biggs: Placed an order online via Jim N Nicks BBQ. My order was completed within the promised time plus it was correct. The tastiest food item was the corn on the cob. I really enjoyed the seasoning. A close second were the muffins. The banana pudding was good but a bit on the sweet side. I also enjoyed the baked beans. The ribs were really good on one hand but waaaaay to salty.

5 /5 Ashley Marion: Every staff member was very helpful. Made the experience great. I ended up stopping the cook Dre, he refilled our drinks without hesitation, and let me know he has to return to the kitchen but other staff members on the floor will assist. The food was cooked to perfection. Everyone wore a smile and moved with grace. For it to be a friends and family event and the staffs first time serving customers, the team was impeccable, couldn’t even tell they were all new.

3 /5 Aundrea Duffy: The service was superb! I was greeted warmly and treated with genuine respect. The staff were extremely helpful and friendly, and the restaurant itself was clean and had a fun, festive atmosphere. My only concern was the food. The burger was drier than expected and not quite to my taste, the mac and cheese noodles were very thick and heavy on the cheese, the deviled eggs had seasoned salt which I didn’t personally enjoy, and the biscuits were just okay, though they were served warm. The prices were great! Overall, I still had a great experience and would return to try a different dish.

1 /5 Vanna M: This was our second time eating here at this location. Both times we ordered online and picked it up. The first time, they forgot a hamburger that my daughter ordered. No big deal. I told someone and they said it was accidentally put in another to-go bag and made another one for us. The food that time was really good. The hamburger was cooked perfectly, the collard greens had a really good taste, and my daughter loved the bbq corn on the cobb. This time, we were really disappointed and I hate that I wasted my money. It was my daughter’s birthday and she requested Jim-N-Nick’s for her birthday dinner. Highly disappointed! To start off, we ordered a single patty cheeseburger with only cheese, mayonnaise, bacon, mustard and ketchup with no onions, lettuce, or tomatoes. What do you know? It was 2 patties, and had everything on it. It also was not cooked properly. Like not just medium rare, the tops of the patties still had a little pink on them. She couldn’t eat it. The corn on the Cobb was not cooked all the way, tasted almost raw. The collard greens were really spicy, which is not how they were last time. My collard greens had mostly meat in them and not many greens at all. My sandwich did not come with coleslaw like it was supposed to. And when I picked up the order, I told the woman at the counter that we also had a sweet tea and she seemed kind of annoyed that she had to go get it. I don’t know if they are training more cooks or what the issue was, but it needs to be fixed. Everything is going up price wise. Eating something out is becoming more of a luxury for some people and I hate that I wasted my money here tonight. We only eat out about once a month and it was not worth the money. Like at all. We definitely will not eat at this location again. I did not drive all the way back to speak to the manager because we live about 30 minutes away and we honestly don’t want any more food from the place anyways.