Italian Pie - Winder (GA)

5 /5 Robert James: Five stars for a much-needed addition to downtown Winder! As a former New Yorker, I know good pizza and this place delivers. The shop is clean, the food is genuinely well-made, and the picnic-table seating adds a casual charm that fits the community. I was genuinely sad when the former business closed, but I’m glad to see a new local spot stepping in and doing it right. Wishing them every success. Highly recommend stopping in and supporting this new business.

5 /5 Jared Wohrley: Absolutely loved everything about this place! It’s about time downtown Winder got a true taste of great Italian pizza. I stopped in on their second day of opening and was immediately impressed. The restaurant is spotless, well put together, and the staff is incredibly friendly and professional. I even had the pleasure of meeting the owner — very polite, engaging, and genuinely passionate about what they’re building here. One of the first things that caught my attention was the size and variety of their menu, especially considering how affordable everything is. Their lunch specials are unbeatable (see photo). My wife and I were able to share the two-slice-and-a-drink combo because the slices were huge and loaded with toppings. I wish I had a picture of my slice, but it looked so good I couldn’t resist digging in right away. My wife loved her mushroom and ham slice — the ham was sliced, not chunked, and the chopped mushrooms gave every bite great flavor. Both of our slices were packed with cheese, and I got a cheese pull with nearly every bite, which is rare these days. Bottom line: this is a fantastic addition to the Winder food community. I highly recommend stopping by and grabbing a slice of heaven.

5 /5 Hunter Lynn: DELICIOUS pizza! So super happy we finally have a good pizza near us. Their subs are just as good! Everything taste homemade if not close to it. I just wish they had a bit better fries but theres plenty more appetizers to choose from. They have great prices for the size as well!

3 /5 Tina Placencia: Pizza and service were great!! We had the garlic knots, Greek salad large, 2 large pizzas, and the churros. We took our 4 young adult children after Christmas. I am changing 5 to 3 stars, with our experience this evening. New Year’s Eve, we decided to go again because we honestly loved the pizza. We called earlier to confirm they would be open after reviewing the website. Was told they would be at 7:30 pm. The website did not have any updated holiday hours or no pop ups. We decided to order as a pickup. Coming from Jefferson, we were 1/2 there and decided to call in our order. It was 7:20 pm and a young lady answered, saying there were closed. I do understand holiday hours. But, the communication was made on my end calling and checking the website. The communication was NOT made as a business. This was disappointing to say the least!!!!

5 /5 Jeffrey Metzger: We’ve been waiting a long time for a “real” pizza place to open again in town. We are sick of the chains and Mazzio’s is a Pizza Hut knockoff. Firstly the pizzas are huge! Ordered two large and they were as big as pizzas in NY state. Good flavor and ingredients. We will definitely be back for sure and hope this place stays open. Best pizza in winder by far!