georgia Date: 09-18-2025

Top 14 Rated Jeweler in Athens, GA (part 2)

Jewelry StoresAddress
1Gateway Jewelry & Pawn3970 Atlanta Hwy Ste. A, Athens, GA 30606
2Antiques & Jewels290 N Milledge Ave, Athens, GA 30601
3Continental Jewelers3700 Atlanta Hwy, Athens, GA 30606
4Something Unique11661 Commerce Rd, Athens, GA 30607
5Margo Metaphysical224 E Clayton St, Athens, GA 30601
6Arete Style171 W Clayton St, Athens, GA 30601
7Aurum Studios Ltd125 E Clayton St, Athens, GA 30601
8Reeves Jewelry & Gold Buyer615 Hawthorne Ave, Athens, GA 30606
9Duncan & Co Fine Jewelry3810 Atlanta Hwy, Athens, GA 30606
10Chandlee Jewelers1850 Epps Bridge Pkwy #213, Athens, GA 30606
11Indie South470 Hawthorne Ave, Athens, GA 30606
12Love Lea Jewelry Designs269 N Jackson St, Athens, GA 30601
13Paragon Style and Design205 Westchester Dr Apt 27, Athens, GA 30606
14Absynia705 Sunset Dr, Athens, GA 30606

1.Gateway Jewelry & Pawn

Address: 3970 Atlanta Hwy Ste. A, Athens, GA 30606

(24) user ratings total:

CountrySwinging Been calling around to get pricing to see the pawnshop that would give me the best price to buy my American silver eagles and the guy literally said they pay $7 for American silver eagles. Trust me that is an extremely lowball of an offer. I would not consider them for future transactions.
1 /5

2.Antiques & Jewels

Address: 290 N Milledge Ave, Athens, GA 30601

(23) user ratings total:

Lindsay Campbell Stopped by looking for nice vintage jewelry and this was the place! Karen was a lovely lady to help us find what we were looking for. My only complaint would be that the jewelry was not the condition she stated. She claimed she looked over all of her jewelry, and on my specific piece there was absolutely no wear and tear, only to walk outside in better light to see the clear wear and tear. In between the chain links there was black dirt that i could just wipe off, leading me to make the assumption that she does not clean her jewelry. She did not tell us what the jewelry was made of until we asked only to find out it was brass with gold coating, as she tried to tell it was 100% gold. Despite this, i still bought the bracelet as i loved it so much. A very minor complaint but still significant to me, she told us it was $120, my boyfriend pulls out $120 CASH and she rings him up and says “128.40” he handed her $130 and we walked out. As an antique store and a small business, it felt unnecessary and just an extra fee for no reason, all of the items are resale items and have already been paid tax on, very disappointing that you still rung him up anyways.
3 /5

3.Continental Jewelers

Address: 3700 Atlanta Hwy, Athens, GA 30606

(22) user ratings total:

Hamp I recently purchased a silver chain from this jewelry shop, and I absolutely love it! The craftsmanship is impeccable and the design is both elegant and timeless. The customer service was outstanding—they made the entire experience enjoyable and stress-free. I highly recommend this shop to anyone in search of beautiful, quality jewelry. Five stars all around!
5 /5

4.Something Unique

Address: 11661 Commerce Rd, Athens, GA 30607

(2) user ratings total:

Bryan Reynolds The store owner, I believe her name was Lisa, was so nice and knowledgeable about the different products she had in store! I will definitely come back to shop for all my accessory needs!
5 /5

5.Margo Metaphysical

Address: 224 E Clayton St, Athens, GA 30601

(198) user ratings total:

Manabendra Ray Best collection of semi precious stones and minerals that I ever visited. Both polished and raw. Curved speciality items. There are also Tarot and many other things sourced from all over the world. The collection is wonderful. I could touch, feel and choose rather than photos on the big online stores which most of the time do not match. I already visited twice. First alone and then again with my daughter. The price is very competitive even with big brand online stores. I will be back again on my next visit to the US.
5 /5

6.Arete Style

Address: 171 W Clayton St, Athens, GA 30601

(17) user ratings total:

Audrey Such an adorable store. The staff is so helpful and helped me pick out the perfect formal dress!!
5 /5

7.Aurum Studios Ltd

Address: 125 E Clayton St, Athens, GA 30601

(158) user ratings total:

Emma Gile We used Aurum for our wedding rings and they were fabulous! They were amazing to work with and helped us customize our rings completely! We worked the most with Lori and she was very helpful throughout the entire process. We were able to text her through the Aurum number and she was very responsive. We still go back to get our rings cleaned and for any jewelry service we may need. Highly recommend!!
5 /5

8.Reeves Jewelry & Gold Buyer

Address: 615 Hawthorne Ave, Athens, GA 30606

(140) user ratings total:

Laura Chapman We recently purchased a replacement wedding set from Reeves jewelry because the diamond in my original set fell out while I was working in the yard 2+ years ago! Greg Reeves was so kind and helpful in scheduling my visit (I live in Alpharetta, GA) and offering guidance as I selected my new wedding set design. I was able to select a new look with a larger diamond (more carats) than my original set for a great price. We decided upon lab grown diamonds and got a great deal costing barely $100 more than what my husband paid for my original mined diamond set in 1996! Mary Alex also did a wonderful job shopping around to get the best deal for a fabulous looking diamond and ring set for us. She also did this extremely quickly and I had my new ring within a few weeks! Thank you, Reeves Jewelry, for a great shopping experience and for the wonderful service!
5 /5

9.Duncan & Co Fine Jewelry

Address: 3810 Atlanta Hwy, Athens, GA 30606

(126) user ratings total:

katie holmes What a great experience, Mrs. Kim is an absolute gem. I didn’t really know what direction I wanted to go in and she not only helped guide me exploring my options but she educated me as well. I love when you find someone that is an expert in their craft. Honestly when we walked in it was a little crowded with people and I was overwhelmed I immediately just wanted to go to Kay’s or Jared’s… I’m glad we didn’t. And we will be back.
5 /5

10.Chandlee Jewelers

Address: 1850 Epps Bridge Pkwy #213, Athens, GA 30606

(1234) user ratings total:

Erin Sharp Staff are very professional and very kind! they have sized 2 watches for me and both were spectacular. I made a strange request to lengthen my watch long enough so it would be a double wrap, and with the stuff i brought them they made it work! absolutely love them and highly recommend.
5 /5

11.Indie South

Address: 470 Hawthorne Ave, Athens, GA 30606

(102) user ratings total:

Molly Harris I have been shopping here for 3 years. Ive always loved it there, but today was different. @3:50pm on Saturday, I came in and was greeted. I said hello, no problem there, but i couldnt find an oil that i got last time there. The girl acted like she didnt know what i was talking about, so i explained it to her. I know products change often, but the way she was acting was like i didnt know what i was talking about. Then proceeded to say the only body oil we have is right there after the third time explaining it to her. It was the oil i wanted, but too big, i asked her if it was all you had and she acted like i was inconveniencing her. Thats poor service. Im in retail so i know what uts like,so i was being nice, she should have given me the kindness. Her vibe was way off, it made me uncomfortable and so I left after buying the big bottle. Normally i stick around to see whats new, but her negative vibe filled the room.
3 /5

12.Love Lea Jewelry Designs

Address: 269 N Jackson St, Athens, GA 30601

(1) user ratings total:

Lucius VanJaager To be frank, I have never been treated so rudely by a complete stranger that calls herself an "outstanding business-lady" in my life. Not that I have ever met anyone with a self proclaimed opinion, but my interaction with this woman had me so upset that I simply had to let others know. If you arent rich, dont bother with this business. All I wanted to do was browse and get a roundabout quote on a ring for my grandson. But instead, she avoided all that and simply asked what my price range was. Taken aback by how rushed she made me feel with her emotionless big eyes glaring at me, I responded with "well, Im thinking between $300-$600 depending on if anything jumps out at me otherwise." So instead of humoring me and letting me down soft with a smile, she very rudely told me that she has nothing to offer unless Im wanting to spend a few grand and that nowhere in Athens would have anything for me. So needless to say, Athens rubbed me wrong on my first outing. Its astounding how one rude business owner of an already run down business can ruin a guys whole idea about an entire county. Dont spend your money here, dont even take a chance on having your good day turned to mud within seconds.
1 /5

13.Paragon Style and Design

Address: 205 Westchester Dr Apt 27, Athens, GA 30606

14.Absynia

Address: 705 Sunset Dr, Athens, GA 30606