The Pie Hometown Pizzeria - Thomaston (GA)

2 /5 Mack Benz: Pizza being the main thing here, it was an interesting experience. Sauce is bland, however the toppings are fresh and were loaded--but man oh man was my pizza severely undercooked. The dough was still gelatinous. I mean it was bad, look at the pictures. No browning on the edges whatsoever. I had to bake it at home. For $20 a pizza, I shouldnt have to do that. It was my first time here and Im sad it didnt live up to its hype. No additional flavour in the crust, no herbs or spices.

1 /5 John Given: We have never been to this establishment before. We walked in and didnt know if we were supposed to seat ourselves or wait to be seated, and there wasnt a sign for it. The place was probably 25% occupied, so not very busy. We looked around and when no one come to welcome us we walked up to the counter and looked at the menu for a few minutes. No one ever said a word to us. We then decided to seat ourselves. No one come over, no one ever spoke to us. We waited several minutes. We left. We decided to go to Slices Pizzeria in downtown. There was a sign at the front door "please wait to be seated." Within seconds someone come over welcomed us and sat us at a table. Within just a couple of minutes a server took our drink order. A stark difference of hospitality and service!

2 /5 Cassidy Bramlett: We ordered a large pepperoni pizza with extra sauce, small butter balls, and a Greek salad. The salad came out with no issues. However, the butter balls were completely undercooked—stringy, doughy, and raw inside. I pulled several apart to check, and none of them were cooked through. I brought them to the counter, and the girl working apologized and eventually issued a refund. When the pizza came out, it was a cheese pizza instead of the pepperoni we ordered. After we pointed out the mistake, they simply added pepperoni on top and ran it back through the oven. The result was a pizza that was extremely dry. The extra sauce we paid for was clearly not added, and the little sauce that was there was dried out. The pepperonis kept falling off and rolling onto the table and floor. We asked for extra sauce and were charged for it, even though we had already paid for extra sauce when we ordered. We didn’t finish the pizza and left the leftovers behind. Unfortunately, this experience wasn’t worth the drive. Next time, we’ll gladly drive the extra 10 minutes to Zebulon for American Pie.

3 /5 The Brown Guy: Theres been a lot of transition at the particular establishment. I know someone who loves their cheese bread and personal pan bacon cheeseburger pizza however. Myself, personally, this wouldnt be my first choice for pizza if I was passing through

2 /5 Anthony: Just can not reccomend this place. Try Slices on the Thomaston square, their service is great, their food is perfectly prepared, and its a nice, welcoming, and bright atmosphere (also has a lovely outdoor seating area). Sadly, the pie is none of those things.