Bennies Red Barn - St Simons Island (GA)

5 /5 Mohammed Ghashim: No words can truly describe how much we loved this place! From the moment we walked in, everything was outstanding. The food was absolutely amazing! I ordered the ribeye steak with a side of cream of corn, and it was cooked perfectly and packed with flavor. You can truly taste the quality of the meat, prepared exactly the way you ask for it. My wife had the salmon and the fried shrimp appetizer, and she loved every bite. Every dish came out fresh, flavorful, and beautifully prepared. The staff made the experience even better incredibly friendly, always smiling, and genuinely welcoming. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel right at home. If you’re visiting Saint Simons, this restaurant is an absolute must. A fantastic dining experience from start to finish. we can’t wait to come back!

5 /5 Grace Meier: We had a wonderful dinner at Bennie’s tonight! Not only was the food fantastic, but the decor was beautiful and the staff was a delight. A special thank you to Sommer for helping make our family dinner special and enjoyable!

5 /5 Mia Delamar: Dropped by last night for a quick dinner about an hour before close. The staff was extremely sweet and attentive. Our server, Rochelle made sure we had everything we needed throughout our dining experience. Every meal comes with complimentary bread and mixed salad, I enjoyed the bread but the salad was a bit soggy, which could have been due to the time of night. I had the 16oz Ribeye and loaded baked potato which was cooked to perfection. Other people in my party had the Surf & Turf and another the Lasagna. Everyone enjoyed their meal and we also purchased a bottle of wine which was very reasonably priced. This a cute establishment with a true barn aesthetic, but a more upscale dining experience truly marrying the best of both worlds. Of you want a good steak or hearty meal, give Bennie’s a try.

4 /5 Take Back Roads: The food was very good overall. The rolls were toasty and tasty, the soups and salads were good as well. The T-bones: the filet side was tender and delicious, but the strip side was very fatty and full of gristle. Our server was very young and inexperienced; she was friendly but made a few small mistakes - not an unpleasant evening at all, she just needs a little more time and experience. Overall, we left fat and happy!

4 /5 Steve Hulsey: Didnt go for a meal. Went with my band to play a corporate Christmas party. Great venue all around. Warm and cozy and the staff was exceptionally friendly and nice.