georgia Date: 08-31-2025

19 Best Insurance Services in Athens, GA

AgentcyAddress
1Larry Baumwald Insurance260 N Milledge Ave, Athens, GA 30601
2Growth Insurance GA3320 Old Jefferson Rd, Athens, GA 30607
3Alfa Insurance - John Waters Agency2350 Prince Ave #2, Athens, GA 30606
4Boswell Group788 Prince Ave, Athens, GA 30606
5Ordinary Policy Insurance Agency2360 Prince Ave, Athens, GA 30606
6Acceptance Insurance2141 W Broad St B, Athens, GA 30606
7Justin Mercer: Allstate Insurance3701 Atlanta Hwy Ste 26, Athens, GA 30606
8Premier Insurance - Athens3620 Atlanta Hwy #A, Athens, GA 30606
9Cole Hixon Insurance, Inc.1640 Prince Ave, Athens, GA 30606
10Merryn Walker: Allstate Insurance570 Gaines School Rd, Athens, GA 30605
11Dana Kerr - State Farm Insurance Agent355 Oneta St Suite D300B, Athens, GA 30601
12Gary Garrett - State Farm Insurance Agent2555 Atlanta Hwy, Athens, GA 30606
13State Farm Insurance1425 S Barnett Shoals Rd, Athens, GA 30605
14Carl A. Blount Insurance Agency325 N Milledge Ave, Athens, GA 30601
15Madison Insurers Athens890 Old Hull Rd, Athens, GA 30601
16Randy Hunt - COUNTRY Financial Agent2092-A, Prince Ave, Athens, GA 30606
17Alvin Penn Hurst: Allstate Insurance760 Hawthorne Ave Ste D, Athens, GA 30606
18La Oficina Insurance Agency121 Rowe Rd, Athens, GA 30601
19Galaxy Tax & Insurance645 Danielsville Rd ste b, Athens, GA 30601

1.Larry Baumwald Insurance

Address: 260 N Milledge Ave, Athens, GA 30601

(41) Clients Are Saying about:

Walker Rudow Leighanne is fantastic, and the entire team at Larry Baumwald Insurance is equally impressive! I highly recommend her and the rest of the staff; they’re all knowledgeable, responsive, and a pleasure to work with.
5 /5
Eryn Everest Im a single mother with a newborn, and I’ve only been in Georgia a few years. I don’t know anyone down here so when looking for car insurance I decided to go with Larry Baumwald Insurance because of all the amazingly positive reviews. They were not wrong. Although I didn’t have roadside set up, I ran out of gas and didn’t have anyone to help, Dustin was an absolute blessing getting me help and showed the perfect southern hospitality. They’ve made a long term customer out of me and I’m so glad to find people who still help without expectations.
5 /5

2.Growth Insurance GA

Address: 3320 Old Jefferson Rd, Athens, GA 30607

(4) Clients Are Saying about:

Maribel Rincon Eli saved me a significant amount every month. I am happy with my new cheaper policy. Thank you for your help
5 /5
Luis Madrid I was referred to this agency by a friend, and I’m so glad I gave them a try. The agent I worked with walked me through every detail of my policy, making sure I understood my policy. It’s reassuring to know I’m covered by such a professional team.
5 /5

3.Alfa Insurance - John Waters Agency

Address: 2350 Prince Ave #2, Athens, GA 30606

images Alfa Insurance - John Waters Agency

(4) Clients Are Saying about:

Cody Barnes John was awesome to work with. Saved me over $150/month on my two cars and was very helpful when I had to make a claim and made sure I was taken care of. If I could give 10 stars I would!
5 /5
Christopher Bolton This place is awesome and so helpful… I wouldn’t go any place else best insurance place ever …….. love it
5 /5

4.Boswell Group

Address: 788 Prince Ave, Athens, GA 30606

(4) Clients Are Saying about:

Bruce Williams Carey Stephens has provided our commercial insurance for years, and saved us money. His experience and trustworthiness have been invaluable to our company.
5 /5
shaream boyd I like this company
5 /5

5.Ordinary Policy Insurance Agency

Address: 2360 Prince Ave, Athens, GA 30606

(4) Clients Are Saying about:

Abel Rivera The fees were clearly laid out and the team helped me avoid unnecessary coverage. I felt confident and informed throughout the process. Best insurance agency I’ve worked with
5 /5
Viridiana Guadalupe Martínez Vargas The agents are helpful, patient and really take the time to ensure you understand your coverage. I’ve saved on my premiums and I feel confident that I have the best coverage for my needs.
5 /5

6.Acceptance Insurance

Address: 2141 W Broad St B, Athens, GA 30606

(394) Clients Are Saying about:

Dulce Yebra Let me start off by this is the place to go if you’re looking for not only great car insurance and fast quotes but amazing customer service. I had the wonderful pleasure of speaking to representative Alexa she was very informative and went above and beyond to meet my needs;not only me an amazing quote quickly, but had so much patience explaining the whole process to me. I love that throughout the entire process of yesterday to today she took me step-by-step as to how I was going to receive the documents and I need to work on them. She has excellent customer service highly recommend if anyone is looking for an amazing quote fast and efficiently. this is your place to go, especially with miss Alexa. She’s a wonderful representative for this organization.
5 /5
Lynn McCullough We truly appreciate acceptance insurance for finding us the best automobile quotes. They are honest and professional. It has been a pleasurable experience. We highly recommend acceptance on Broad Street Athens.
5 /5

7.Justin Mercer: Allstate Insurance

Address: 3701 Atlanta Hwy Ste 26, Athens, GA 30606

(39) Clients Are Saying about:

Cliff Dorsen Justin was fantastic. Not only did he save me literally thousands of dollars, he made the process seamless with clarity as to all options and coverages. I wanted to see if I could save money on a policy that would cover two homes and three automobiles, including three drivers, without losing any coverage. Not an easy task. I am now paying half what I was paying my prior insurer for even better coverage than I had before. Justin was great about listening to my concerns and what coverages were important to me and clearly explaining the options as to coverage and also kept in mind my goal of saving money from what I was paying before. Im a busy person, and he made the whole process easy and did it on my schedule. Overall, a great experience, and I would highly recommend his services to anyone looking to see if they can save money and get quality coverage that best suits their needs.
5 /5
Dev Byrd Definitely 10/10! Susan did such an awesome job helping me out with my car insurance! She guided me and told me step by step all the savings I am entitled too and has such a awesome customer service personality! She deserves a raise and deserves so much praise for her wonderful service!
5 /5

8.Premier Insurance - Athens

Address: 3620 Atlanta Hwy #A, Athens, GA 30606

(38) Clients Are Saying about:

kelley smith Been with the company since they opened. Ben and Melissa are great people. Worked there 2 times. Best rates. I love it and them. Highly recommend.
5 /5
Kim Thompson Very reasonable rates. The only thing I dont like is the make you come all the way to theyre office to sign papers or bring stuff in instead of using emails or fax . Its very inconvenient because Im out if town a lot and Ive had to cut my other business shirt several times to go in and sign stuff. They need to get up to speed with the changing times.
2 /5

9.Cole Hixon Insurance, Inc.

Address: 1640 Prince Ave, Athens, GA 30606

(38) Clients Are Saying about:

Melanie Baringer I recently worked with Melanie Covington at Cole Hixon Insurance, and I couldn’t be more impressed! She helped me update and change all of my insurance needs quickly and efficiently. Melanie made the entire process so smooth, explaining everything clearly and ensuring I had the best coverage. Her professionalism and responsiveness were top-notch, and I felt confident every step of the way. If youre looking for someone who truly cares about your needs, I highly recommend reaching out to Melanie!
5 /5
Whitney Goyen I was looking for a local broker for business insurance and Cole Hixon team has more than met our needs. Mark assisted with our health policies and Doug with our business policies and both have been a dream to work with. I highly recommend their level of expertise and superior customer service. I look forward to working with them for years to come!
5 /5

10.Merryn Walker: Allstate Insurance

Address: 570 Gaines School Rd, Athens, GA 30605

(38) Clients Are Saying about:

Keith and Susan Sanders Merryn Walker has been my Allstate agent for at least 20 years. Shes great to work with for advice, suggestions, with whatever help I need. Merryn is very level-headed and easy to talk with.
5 /5
Arthur Owen Saved me a lot of money on the premiums and received better coverage. She listened and made recommendations based on our needs. Good to have a local representative that you can talk to face to face and a reliable, well known company. Well see if the rates jump up upon renewal, but for now, very pleased.
5 /5

11.Dana Kerr - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 355 Oneta St Suite D300B, Athens, GA 30601

(36) Clients Are Saying about:

Chas Ive been a customer with State Farm for years. Dana, Jackson, and the team have treated my family like their own. Very transparent and honest business. 10/10 service with every encounter. Ill recommend their services to anyone.
5 /5
Persnickety Designs I am appalled at the lack of engagement after our daughter was hit by a driver on vacation in Florida. Dana Kerr’s State Farm refused to even call back on the threat that if they helped or did anything to get a decent amount to replace their car he would open a claim and it would go on their record and raise their rates. Would not even return a call to speak to her or her husband. No help or advice in working with the manipulation of the other insurance company. No, hope you are ok, how can I help, let me help you work with them. Do not do business with Dana Kerr!! Find a caring reputable company and agent to work with for your insurance needs.
1 /5

12.Gary Garrett - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 2555 Atlanta Hwy, Athens, GA 30606

(30) Clients Are Saying about:

Amanda Moore Gary Garrett State Farm and his employees are top notch! Logan Moore was very respectful and helpful when helping me file my claim and getting my repairs done in a timely manner. Can not beat the customer service I have received from this State Farm Agency
5 /5
Jeff Dawson This office is fantastic. On several occasions their amazing customer service got me out of a pinch. One time in Canada, a car rental company refused me a rental until I showed them a specific form from State Farm proving coverage in Canada. I was running very late to an important event. So I made a call to Gary Garretts office and explained the situation. Moments later they emailed me the specific form with my name, policy number and other information on it. There were a number of occasions like that where they were extremely quick and responsive...and always so nice and friendly. Im really glad I went with them for auto and renters insurance during my time in Athens, GA.
5 /5

13.State Farm Insurance

Address: 1425 S Barnett Shoals Rd, Athens, GA 30605

(30) Clients Are Saying about:

CatLady71 The prices of State Farm in general are ok...Ive been using them for 4 years with auto, home and life insurance. Very happy with Mike Dekle Agency. Special shout out to Tharsis and Libby who work there and are always friendly and helpful.
5 /5
Noah Parker I’ve passed by this State Farm office every day since I moved to Athens. Mike Dekle has been a staple of my daily commute for the last 5 years. I’ve never used State Farm and have no idea who this man is but shout out to my boy Mike. I’d like to extend a bittersweet congratulations to Shane Dekle, I’ll be reading your name every day now.
5 /5

14.Carl A. Blount Insurance Agency

Address: 325 N Milledge Ave, Athens, GA 30601

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

kim antrim How does one know they have a fantastic insurance agent? When you file a claim and get superb help from your agent during the process. Carl intervened on a few occasions and acted as a conduit between me, the customer, and the adjusters to iron out some issues. His help is invaluable!
5 /5
Wombat Rescue Friendly, always responds and answers thoroughly.
5 /5

15.Madison Insurers Athens

Address: 890 Old Hull Rd, Athens, GA 30601

images Madison Insurers Athens

(3) Clients Are Saying about:

Lee Porterfield This place canceled my policy after having it for years because they said something about it was zoned for agriculture not a home but what it actually was is I had zoned the house and two acres for residential and the other 20 something acres that joined the home was zoned for agriculture and this was done a decade before I got the house insured with these people and it was fine then??? So when I got the notice that they would be canceling my policy I called them to discuss this facts but they wouldnt have any of my explanation they said that I had to go to the tax office and get proof???? Which is weird as those records are public and they could have pulled it up their self? In any case Covid hit before I could get back up there(I live in a different city) so there were shut down so by the time the quarantine was over my policy had been canceled and they will not even meet with me in person face to face they just refuse to see me and they stopped taking my calls about it? So very unprofessional on many levels and I couldnt get coverage again due to laps in service??? I would stay far away from this business they are awful in so many ways. And I never write bad reviews as mom told me if you do have anything nice to say best to not say anything but I had to put this truth out there to help inform others of there incompetence and unprofessional behavior.
2 /5
Nancy Callahan Great customer service! We spoke on the phone the previous day and Jessica(?) put together a quote for me. I was able to save a lot of money too.
5 /5

16.Randy Hunt - COUNTRY Financial Agent

Address: 2092-A, Prince Ave, Athens, GA 30606

(28) Clients Are Saying about:

Kristi Casey Randy and Janine we so helpful in finding all the discounts for our NEW driver. The driving app that saves us money also is a great way to track his driving and make sure he is being safe. They also made sure we had the correct coverage for what we needed without trying to give us coverage for what we dont.
5 /5
Blake Hartis Sam at Country Financial has been great. He always takes time to talk with me, discover my needs and review my options to get me the coverage thats right for me at the best value, hell even be honest and up front if theres something he cant get you the best value on. Hes always prompt to respond and provides excellent service. I would highly recommend talking with Sam about your insurance needs.
5 /5

17.Alvin Penn Hurst: Allstate Insurance

Address: 760 Hawthorne Ave Ste D, Athens, GA 30606

(26) Clients Are Saying about:

Caleb B. Mr. Hurst always goes above and beyond to make sure all my insurance needs are taken care of. Any time there may be a change to my policy or an opportunity for me to save money he lets me know. In this day in time it is refreshing to have someone take you and your financial needs into consideration. I recommend him to anyone I come into contact with looking for insurance to him.
5 /5
Nao Warr I believe that Allstate does not think of the Customers who have been with them for a very long time. To raise the payment like they do, tells me they take their customers for granted. When you do this, you lose customers. There are many of us who will only go so far.
3 /5

18.La Oficina Insurance Agency

Address: 121 Rowe Rd, Athens, GA 30601

(25) Clients Are Saying about:

Yesenia Juarez I love how they educated there customers on different insurance policy explaining the different coverages out there
5 /5
Diana Farfán They are excellent professionals
5 /5

19.Galaxy Tax & Insurance

Address: 645 Danielsville Rd ste b, Athens, GA 30601

(25) Clients Are Saying about:

Samantha Zepp I have been filing my taxes with Galaxy for at least 13 years or more. I will continue to use them because I’ve always been truly happy with the service they provide at Galaxy Tax. I have referred my close friends and family and I definitely recommend them for everyone. Crystal is my go-to tax preparer, she is sweet as can be. Thank you Galaxy Tax for 13 years of great service.
5 /5
michael barnett My experience with Victor Perez and Galaxy Tax & Insurance was outstanding. They took great care of me, made the process smooth, and got me exactly what I needed. I’m truly thankful for their excellent service.
5 /5