georgia Date: 08-31-2025

15 Best Insurance Services in Milledgeville, GA

AgentcyAddress
1Steven Stancil American Family Insurance1640 N Columbia St, Milledgeville, GA 31061
2Murphey Insurance Inc145 Garrett Way, Milledgeville, GA 31061
3NavSav Insurance - Milledgeville1531 N Columbia St, Milledgeville, GA 31061
4Alfa Insurance - Lazaro Valle Agency130 Log Cabin Rd NE Unit A, Milledgeville, GA 31061
5Georgia Farm Bureau452 S Wayne St, Milledgeville, GA 31061
6Andy Cowart - State Farm Insurance Agent110 Executive Pkwy, Milledgeville, GA 31061
7Sinclair Oconee Agency, LLC1776 N Jefferson St NE # C, Milledgeville, GA 31061
8Health Insurance Options3015 Heritage Rd # 5, Milledgeville, GA 31061
9Dustin Faulkner: Allstate Insurance3006 Heritage Rd STE B, Milledgeville, GA 31061
10Merritt Massey - State Farm Insurance Agent3006 Heritage Rd ste d, Milledgeville, GA 31061
11Craig-Massee Insurance Agency1947 N Jefferson St NE, Milledgeville, GA 31061
12Eagle Protection Insurance2691 Irwinton Rd, Milledgeville, GA 31061
13Rhett Harrison Commercial Insurance3015 Heritage Rd #2, Milledgeville, GA 31061
14Ritta Harden - COUNTRY Financial Agent1820 N Columbia St # B, Milledgeville, GA 31061
15Bill Dyer452 S Wayne St, Milledgeville, GA 31061

1.Steven Stancil American Family Insurance

Address: 1640 N Columbia St, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(32) Clients Are Saying about:

Troy Ballew Steven and Deb are awesome people!! They truly care about your needs and treat you like family. I recommend them to anyone that I hear talking about insurance needs.
5 /5
Alex Santillan Steve was great. I called for a quote on home owners insurance after hours and he promptly returned my call with a quote the next day. He spent the time to look at my car insurance while he had me on the line and laid out how much I could save with a home/auto bundle. He never pressured me into purchasing anything. He simply laid out facts based on my current plan with my previous insurer. He gave me the time I needed to verify the information he gave me and when I was ready to move forward he laid out all of the next steps in detail and told me to call him at any time if I had questions or concerns. Overall, he made the process extremely painless and earned my trust pretty quickly. I’ve already referred him to a few family members.
5 /5

2.Murphey Insurance Inc

Address: 145 Garrett Way, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(30) Clients Are Saying about:

Patt Dyal Very helpful and friendly staff originally. Definitely a 5 star business. However, I have called twice and emailed and cannot get anyone to return my calls or help me. This continues on week two!!
1 /5
John Knowles Great group of people they were able to save me a bunch of money on my car and Home Insurance highly recommend
5 /5

3.NavSav Insurance - Milledgeville

Address: 1531 N Columbia St, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(24) Clients Are Saying about:

Tree Love Montana Ingram SAVED ME OVER 300 dollars with insurance LOVEEEE THIS COMPANY YOURS TRUELY SHANICIA
5 /5
Gerald Gilmore I would recommend them to anyone who is looking for a insurance company. Hannah took the time to explain to me all of my coverages in depth. Answer all my emails and questions and never once made me feel like I was bothering her. Customer service at its best. Thanks Hannah!
5 /5

4.Alfa Insurance - Lazaro Valle Agency

Address: 130 Log Cabin Rd NE Unit A, Milledgeville, GA 31061

images Alfa Insurance - Lazaro Valle Agency

(24) Clients Are Saying about:

Richard Kimbrell Always professional and quick to help you with any issues that you have. Customer Service is great! Switched to them a couple years ago and I have had a great experience. Would definitely recommend.
5 /5
Amanda Hendricks Everyone is always super nice & friendly. They are always willing to help in anyway they can. They was able to help me get a policy and save money.
5 /5

5.Georgia Farm Bureau

Address: 452 S Wayne St, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(24) Clients Are Saying about:

Tanya Vargas Great insurance can pay 6 months at a time..In store and online service.
5 /5
Pat Griffin It was helping and Individual was pleasant and attentive to my concerns.
4 /5

6.Andy Cowart - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 110 Executive Pkwy, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(24) Clients Are Saying about:

Aleja I recommend Andy and his team!! They provide truly exceptional service. As someone living with multiple sclerosis, making policy changes and managing payments has often been a challenge, but Lauren has been incredibly accommodating and proactive in helping me understand my options when needed, and draft my payments smoothly. Their empathy and efficiency make a real difference. Thank you for making things so much easier!
5 /5
Teresa Kennedy Im writing to express my sincere appreciation for the exceptional service we consistently receive from Andy and his entire staff. It has truly always been a pleasure working with them. In particular, Lauren has been an invaluable resource. She is consistently available to answer any questions we have regarding our policies and is incredibly helpful with any claims we need to process. The level of support and responsiveness she provides is truly outstanding. I would rate their service 10/10!
5 /5

7.Sinclair Oconee Agency, LLC

Address: 1776 N Jefferson St NE # C, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(20) Clients Are Saying about:

Cassandra Zimmerle Mr. Ashley and Mr. Jerry is amazing!! Mr. Ashley helped my husband and I with our auto insurance and renters, now Mr. Ashley has helped with our homeowners and has stepped us through it. Mr. Jerry is very patient and helped find my mother life insurance and answered any questions I had. I would recommend them to anyone.
5 /5
Tracy Hall I highly recommend this business! Ashely was heavenly sent for all my insurance needs. He got me the best rates and was very informative.There was some things needed to be taken care of and Ashley was more like a friend than an agent. If you’re looking for a great agency, look no further than Sinclair Insurance Agency. You will be very pleased.
5 /5

8.Health Insurance Options

Address: 3015 Heritage Rd # 5, Milledgeville, GA 31061

9.Dustin Faulkner: Allstate Insurance

Address: 3006 Heritage Rd STE B, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(18) Clients Are Saying about:

Jared Rickerson Amazing experience. We were able to come in and discuss a very reasonable quote which was a lot better than our current Insurance. It saved us hundreds. Anija was very helpful with the whole process. If you need insurance, you are truly in good hands with Alstate.
5 /5
Sheri Litchfield After over 25 years with Allstate and their refusals to provide pricing discounts on multiple occasions, I went with equally quoted insurance and was able to get both car and homeowners insurance for a total monthly savings of $87. So if you are looking, give it a try. I did
1 /5

10.Merritt Massey - State Farm Insurance Agent

Address: 3006 Heritage Rd ste d, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(156) Clients Are Saying about:

Love Chandy (ChandyTrue) Alan is absolutely phenomenal! From the moment I walked into Merritt Massey’s State Farm office, Alan made the experience seamless and stress-free. He’s incredibly knowledgeable, patient, and truly takes the time to understand your needs. Alan explained everything clearly and made sure I felt confident in my choices. His professionalism and friendly attitude made the whole process enjoyable. If you’re looking for someone who genuinely cares and goes the extra mile, ask for Alan—you won’t be disappointed!
5 /5
JoAnn Smith I was so pleased with my visit today at Merritt Massey State Farm Agency. I was wanting to get quotes on my car and home owners insurance. My car insurance cost had doubled since last year! I was helped by Amy Burgamy. She was able to help me evaluate my existing policies and show me where I could get better rates and better coverage with State Farm. She was extremely knowledgeable , pleasant and accommodating. I signed up right away and am pleased to be a State Farm customer. I will be recommending her and the agency to my friends and family. Thank you so much for being so kind, supportive and helpful.
5 /5

11.Craig-Massee Insurance Agency

Address: 1947 N Jefferson St NE, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(14) Clients Are Saying about:

Patricia Farley Well I called Craig-Massee about an old bill that needed to be resolved that I had no clue about until I was getting a insurance quote from another insurance agency. They were very nice about letting me know what the owed amount was.
4 /5
Skyler Kicklighter I love this place. Glenda is great at finding the best coverage to fit your needs and is great at trying to help you save! Definitely recommend this place for car insurance coverage.
5 /5

12.Eagle Protection Insurance

Address: 2691 Irwinton Rd, Milledgeville, GA 31061

images Eagle Protection Insurance

(13) Clients Are Saying about:

Aaron Wilson Shout out to Mr. Tyler Allen. Great customer service, was very professional. As a customer I really appreciate that. Keep up the good work. Thanks again.
5 /5
Benjamin Renfroe Always sweet make sure they take the time to fulfill the insurance that you can handle in need
5 /5

13.Rhett Harrison Commercial Insurance

Address: 3015 Heritage Rd #2, Milledgeville, GA 31061

(1) Clients Are Saying about:

Kay Barker Mary is very helpful, professional and kind
5 /5

14.Ritta Harden - COUNTRY Financial Agent

Address: 1820 N Columbia St # B, Milledgeville, GA 31061

15.Bill Dyer

Address: 452 S Wayne St, Milledgeville, GA 31061